Football has a way of reminding us that players do not suddenly become bad overnight.
Looking at Mohamed Salah, Cody Gakpo and Alexis Mac Allister, Liverpool supporters have a reasonable question to ask:
Were some of them ever really the problem?
Richard Hughes and Arne Slot’s time at Liverpool already looks different with the benefit of hindsight. Salah has left and is thriving with Trabzonspor, Gakpo has become one of Andoni Iraola’s most important players, and Mac Allister is beginning to resemble the midfielder Liverpool knew he could be.
Maybe the problem was not always the players.
Salah being ‘finished’ looks ridiculous now
Liverpool were repeatedly told that Salah was entering the twilight of his career and was no longer the same player. The club eventually moved on, with his final appearance coming against Brentford, where he assisted Curtis Jones and finished his Liverpool career as the club’s outright record-holder for Premier League assists.
Now, Salah has scored seven goals in six Turkish league appearances, including a hat-trick and an assist in Trabzonspor’s 4-0 win over Galatasaray.
Playing in Turkey is not the same as playing in the Premier League, but the point remains: Salah has not forgotten how to play. His movement, finishing and hunger are still there, leaving Liverpool supporters to wonder what might have been had he stayed at Anfield.
Gakpo and Mac Allister show the same pattern
Gakpo is perhaps the clearest example of a player who should not have been written off. Liverpool were reportedly prepared to consider a significant offer for him during the summer, with Manchester City among the clubs linked. Instead, he stayed, and his performances under Iraola are making that decision look increasingly important.
Gakpo struggled for consistency under Slot, often looking frustrated and ineffective. Under Iraola, however, he appears more confident, direct and dangerous. He scored in Liverpool’s 3-1 Carabao Cup win over Tottenham, despite the Reds making ten changes.
Mac Allister has undergone a similar transformation. Last season, the Argentine sometimes looked ordinary and struggled to impose himself on matches. Now, his intelligence, passing, aggression and confidence are returning. He scored Liverpool’s opener against Tottenham with a superb first-time finish, again in a heavily rotated side.
These are not players who suddenly rediscovered their ability. They are players who appear to be benefiting from a better environment and clearer structure.
The system matters
It would be too simplistic to blame everything on Slot. He won the Premier League title with Liverpool and enjoyed considerable success, although his final season became increasingly difficult before his departure.
However, several players who looked below their best during that period have since shown they were capable of much more.
When a team is not functioning properly, individual players can become victims of the system. A midfielder may struggle because the structure around him is poor, while a forward can look ineffective if he receives the ball in the wrong areas. Confidence can also disappear when every mistake is magnified.
That is why Hughes’ decisions deserve a second look. His Liverpool tenure is reportedly coming to an end after the summer transfer window, but Gakpo’s situation shows the value of patience. Had Liverpool sold him and watched him flourish elsewhere, supporters would likely have questioned why another talented attacker had been allowed to leave.
Liverpool may not need to rebuild as much as expected
The biggest lesson may be that a new manager does not always need to tear everything apart. Sometimes the priority is simply getting more from the players already at the club.
Gakpo and Mac Allister already look different, and there are signs that others could improve too. If Iraola can revive players who appeared ordinary last season, Liverpool’s squad may contain considerably more quality than many assumed.
The irony is that Salah, the player Liverpool can no longer benefit from, is providing the clearest reminder. He is scoring in Turkey, Gakpo is thriving at Liverpool and Mac Allister is looking like himself again.
Maybe they were never finished. Maybe they were never bad players. Maybe Liverpool simply were not getting the best out of them.
Good footballers should not be written off too quickly. Sometimes they need the right system, the right manager and a fresh start.
Jamie (The Kopite View)
