I’ve been thinking about Jürgen Klopp and his Liverpool team since the news about Manchester City broke.
Not because I think everything should suddenly be rewritten.
It shouldn’t.
But when you look back at what Liverpool achieved while competing against Manchester City, it is hard not to appreciate Klopp’s legacy even more.
An independent commission has found City guilty of serious financial rule breaches covering the period from 2009/10 to 2017/18. The Premier League says the commission found that City used “sham” commercial arrangements which artificially inflated revenues and reduced costs by more than £900m. It also found three of four alleged breaches relating to the club’s cooperation with the Premier League investigation. City can appeal the findings, and the sanction has not yet been decided.
Those are incredibly serious findings.
And obviously Liverpool fans are going to look back at some of those title races and wonder what might have been.
I certainly have.
97 points and still second
The one that always comes back to me is 2018/19.
Liverpool got 97 points.
Ninety-seven.
They lost one league game all season and still didn’t win the title.
City got 98.
One point.
It was heartbreaking at the time. I remember thinking that surely a team couldn’t do much more than that and still finish second.
Then Liverpool came back the following season and won the league with 99 points.
That is one of the things I think gets forgotten when people talk about Klopp’s Liverpool.
They weren’t just a good team.
They were ridiculously good.
And they had to be.
Because City kept setting the bar higher.
Then came 2021/22 and we had another ridiculous title race.
Liverpool finished on 92 points.
City finished on 93.
Another one-point difference.
You can’t look at that and tell me Klopp’s team wasn’t good enough.
They were good enough to win the league in most seasons.
They just happened to be competing against a team that kept finding another point, another win and another way of getting over the line.
What do we do with that now?
This is where I think Liverpool supporters need to be sensible.
The commission’s findings are serious, but today’s decision doesn’t mean Liverpool are suddenly going to be handed titles from previous seasons.
We don’t know what the eventual sanctions will be.
We don’t know what happens after City’s appeal, if they choose to take it.
And we don’t know what the Premier League will ultimately decide about the historical consequences.
So I’m not going to sit here and tell you Liverpool should now have extra titles on their record.
That’s for the process to decide.
But I do think the findings change the way you look at that era.
For years Liverpool were trying to compete with City while the Premier League was investigating the club over its finances.
Now an independent commission has made its findings.
That’s a pretty significant difference from simply talking about allegations.
Klopp deserves enormous credit
What I find most impressive is what Klopp did with Liverpool anyway.
He didn’t have unlimited resources.
He didn’t need to spend £100m every time he wanted to improve the team.
He built a side.
Alisson.
Van Dijk.
Robertson.
Alexander-Arnold.
Fabinho.
Henderson.
Salah.
Mane.
Firmino.
And so many others who became part of one of the best Liverpool teams I’ve ever watched.
Then they went toe-to-toe with City year after year.
And when Liverpool lost that 2018/19 title by a single point, Klopp didn’t allow the players to feel sorry for themselves.
They went again.
That’s what I remember most.
Not the fact that City had 98 points.
I remember Liverpool getting 97.
Not the fact City got 93 in 2021/22.
I remember Liverpool getting 92 and still winning two cups that season.
That tells you something about Klopp.
I don’t want to rewrite Liverpool’s history
There is a temptation now to look back and say: Liverpool should have won this. Liverpool should have won that.
Maybe.
But I’d rather celebrate what that team actually achieved.
The Champions League.
The Premier League.
The FA Cup.
The League Cup.
The Club World Cup.
The 97-point season.
The 99-point title-winning season.
The 92-point season.
The comeback against Barcelona.
The 4-0 against them at Anfield.
Those moments belong to Liverpool supporters.
Nobody can take them away.
And if anything, knowing that Liverpool were competing at that level while City are now dealing with these findings makes Klopp’s achievements feel even more remarkable to me.
I’m not saying Liverpool should automatically be given anything.
I’m saying look at what Klopp managed to build.
He took Liverpool from a team trying to get back into the Champions League to a side that could go toe-to-toe with Manchester City for years.
And he did it with a group of players who were pushed to extraordinary levels.
The hardest part for City fans
There is another side to this that I don’t want to ignore.
I said this in my previous article and I’ll say it again: I feel sorry for Manchester City supporters.
They didn’t arrange sponsorship agreements.
They didn’t prepare financial accounts.
They didn’t decide how the club responded to the Premier League investigation.
They just supported their team.
Now they have to deal with the findings and whatever comes next.
That’s horrible for any supporter.
Rivalry is one thing. Laughing at your mates because your team has beaten theirs is football.
But supporters shouldn’t be blamed for what happens in the boardroom.
Whatever happens next, Klopp’s record stands
City have the right to appeal the commission’s findings and the sanction still has to be decided.
So this isn’t the end of the story.
But for Liverpool fans, I think it’s worth taking a moment to appreciate what we watched under Klopp.
We saw a Liverpool team collect 97 points and finish second.
We saw them lose a title by one point and come back with 99 points.
We saw them finish with 92 points and still lift two domestic cups.
We saw a manager build one of the greatest Liverpool sides of the modern era and keep finding ways to compete.
So yes, the findings against Manchester City are serious.
And if further sanctions eventually affect the history of those seasons, we can talk about that when the time comes.
For now, though, I don’t need a commission to tell me what Klopp’s Liverpool were.
They were bloody brilliant.
And looking back at those title races now, I appreciate that team more than ever.
Jamie (The Kopite View)
