Liverpool have received further confirmation that a controversial penalty decision went against them, with the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel unanimously agreeing that the spot-kick awarded against Milos Kerkez was incorrect.
The incident came during Liverpool’s 3-1 victory over Crystal Palace, when Kerkez challenged Darío Osorio for the ball in the closing stages.
Referee Tony Harrington pointed to the spot, with Eddie Nketiah converting to make it 3-1.
Liverpool were understandably frustrated at the time, particularly because replays showed both players jumping to contest the ball and the resulting contact appeared inevitable.
Now the KMI Panel has backed that interpretation.
Unanimous verdict – but VAR escapes criticism
The panel unanimously felt that the penalty should not have been awarded.
Its view was that contact was inevitable because of the jumping actions of both players.
In other words, this was an aerial contest rather than a foul by Kerkez.
However, there is another part of the verdict that will leave Liverpool supporters scratching their heads.
Despite agreeing that the original decision was wrong, the panel supported VAR’s decision not to intervene because the error was not considered clear and obvious.
So the referee made the wrong call, but VAR was still deemed correct not to send him to the monitor.
That is the frustrating distinction at the heart of the current VAR system.
Another controversial decision involving Liverpool
What makes this particularly difficult for Liverpool supporters to accept is the timing.
Only recently, the KMI Panel ruled that Liverpool should have been awarded a penalty against Arsenal after Jurrien Timber pulled Alexander Isak’s shirt inside the penalty area.
Four of the five panel members believed a penalty should have been given, while a majority also felt VAR should have intervened.
Liverpool lost that game 1-0.
Now we have another incident involving the Reds where the panel has acknowledged that the on-field decision was incorrect, but the VAR outcome has been supported.
The two incidents are not identical, and the VAR threshold is an important distinction. But supporters are entitled to ask why the system continues to leave so much room for debate.
Iraola was right to be frustrated
Andoni Iraola was furious after the Crystal Palace match, particularly because he felt Liverpool were being treated differently when it came to penalty decisions.
His frustration was not simply about conceding a penalty in a game Liverpool were winning comfortably.
It was about consistency and the standards being applied.
A clean sheet matters, and Liverpool had worked hard to protect their lead. The late penalty took that away from them unnecessarily.
For me, the KMI verdict is important because it confirms what many Liverpool supporters were saying immediately after the incident: Kerkez should not have been penalised for an unavoidable collision while both players were challenging for the ball.
I understand the argument that VAR should only intervene in clear and obvious errors. But when an independent panel unanimously agrees that a penalty was wrongly awarded, it is difficult not to question whether the system is delivering the accountability supporters expect.
Liverpool got the three points at Selhurst Park, thankfully.
But the bigger issue remains.
We don’t expect referees to get every decision right. We do expect consistency, common sense and a VAR system that actually helps correct clear mistakes.
By Jamie (The Kopite View)

Leave a Reply