How many times do Liverpool supporters have to hear that the officials got it wrong before something changes?
We are only a relatively short way into the Premier League season, yet three major penalty decisions involving Liverpool have already been judged incorrectly by the independent Key Match Incidents Panel.
And the frustrating thing is that supporters were questioning these decisions immediately. In some cases, you didn’t need to be a qualified referee to see why they were wrong.
1. Alisson against Nottingham Forest
Liverpool were controversially penalised after Alisson made contact with Neco Williams during Forest’s visit to Anfield.
Sam Barrott pointed to the spot, allowing Morgan Gibbs-White to put Forest ahead.
The KMI Panel subsequently voted 3-2 that the penalty should not have been awarded, explaining that the contact was inevitable because of Alisson’s momentum as he attempted to make the save.
VAR did not intervene, despite the original decision being incorrect.
2. Jurrien Timber’s shirt pull on Alexander Isak
This one was particularly frustrating.
Liverpool were chasing an equaliser against Arsenal when Isak was pulled back by Timber inside the penalty area as he attempted to attack a cross.
Nothing was given by referee Andy Madley, and VAR Stuart Attwell allowed the decision to stand.
The KMI Panel later voted 4-1 that Liverpool should have received a penalty, with a 3-2 majority also believing VAR should have intervened.
Liverpool lost the game 1-0.
That decision could have made a significant difference to the result.
3. Kerkez penalised against Crystal Palace
Most recently, Milos Kerkez was penalised for his aerial challenge on Dario Osorio during Liverpool’s 3-1 victory over Crystal Palace.
The decision looked harsh at the time, with both players jumping to contest the ball and contact appearing inevitable.
The KMI Panel has now unanimously agreed that the penalty was incorrectly awarded.
However, it supported VAR’s decision not to intervene because the error was not considered clear and obvious.
Once again, Liverpool were left on the receiving end of a decision that the independent panel subsequently judged to be wrong.
When does it become a problem?
Let’s be fair: referees are human, and mistakes will happen in football.
But what is the point of having VAR if supporters are repeatedly left watching decisions that later turn out to be incorrect?
Two penalties have wrongly been awarded against Liverpool, while a clear majority of the KMI Panel agreed that the Reds should have received a spot-kick against Arsenal.
That’s three significant penalty decisions involving Liverpool, and all three have gone against them on the pitch.
The Newcastle penalty awarded against Liverpool earlier in the season was judged correct, so I’m not suggesting every decision has been wrong. But the pattern in these three incidents is frustrating enough.
The Premier League can publish its KMI findings every week, but that doesn’t change the result or give Liverpool back points that may have been lost.
Supporters don’t expect perfection. They expect consistency and accountability.
And when decisions are being overturned in the court of public opinion after the matches, questions have to be asked.
Liverpool need the officials to start getting the big decisions right – not simply admitting afterwards that they got them wrong.
By Jamie (The Kopite View)

Leave a Reply